Joan Fontcuberta at the European House of Photography

An initiatory journey strewn with invisible pitfalls, that is what the MEP offers. The visitor learns of the existence of fossils of the hydropithecus, a creature mid-animal, half-human whose skeleton ends in a fish tail, discovers the space odyssey of cosmonaut Ivan Istochnikov, investigates a community of Finnish Orthodox monks and then, with a final flourish, loses their bearings in art history when they understand the considerable impact of photography on the work of Picasso, Miró, Tàpies and Dalí. After this suspicious journey whose unity and meaning they do not understand, they still have not found the room dedicated to the work of Joan Fontcuberta… And then, suddenly, everything comes together, becomes clear and makes sense: the artist, a master illusionist, has deceived them. The visitor, duped, blames themselves for their naivety, fully excused by the quality of Fontcuberta's work. A true coming-of-age novel in which we are both the heroes and the victims, the exhibition Camouflages teaches us to our own detriment to be wary of the photographic image. Photographer, theorist, critic, professor and historian, the Spanish artist questions the truth. Through the manipulation of the photographic image, he draws us into an invented reality that nevertheless seems plausible. Thus, the hypothesis of the existence of the hydropithecus is supported by traces of bones on the site, interviews with specialists, scientific studies… We are then tempted, like Ulysses, to listen to the song of these prehistoric sirens. His capacity for fabulation and the ease with which the artist manipulates us ultimately raises this question: to what extent should we believe the truth uttered by scientists, religion, the media and politicians? Thus, while Fontcuberta plays and amuses us, his goal is to arouse awareness in the viewer: "We must doubt what is said by institutions that may have a monopoly on discourse (…) Science only represents provisional truths, it is merely a way of telling us reality".
Back to Cartesian doubt, still and always relevant!
Camouflages, Joan Fontcuberta, from January 15 to March 16 2014, Maison européenne de la photographie, 5/7 rue de Fourcy, 75004 Paris, metro: Saint-Paul.

Text: Anna Bogdanoff